Tree Ring Analysis: Problems of Dating 1: The Medicine Valley Sites

$20.00

1 in stock

Description

Author: Gladwin, Harold Sterling  (1883-1983)

Publisher: Gila Pueblo (Globe, AZ)

Pub Date: 1944

Binding: Paperback

Condition: Poor.  Stapled binding is attached to text body, but not by much.  Previous owner’s stamp on upper front cover corner.  Front cover bottome edge has an approx. 3/4″ missing chip.  Smudges to front cover (old price markings?).  Spine is torn at least half-way down from head, worn, chipped.  Rear cover has a chip at spine edge, about half-way down from head.  Lower rear cover edge has two tears, one approx.1/2″, a second approx. 1/8″.   It’s the covers overlapping the text block that has caused these edge and spine problems.

Notes:  Gladwin was like a dog with a bone when it came to tree-ring dating.  He was unconvinced that tree-ring dating could supplant ceramics and architecture as a reliable dating method, or, using tree-ring dating as an adjunct dating method, all other archaeological dates would have to be adjusted/corrected.  “The doubts which I have cast upon the accuracy of tree-ring dates for sites near Flagstaff demand substantiation which, in turn, will require a comprehensive review of the whole subject of dating by means of tree-rings.” (From “A Review and Analysis of Flagstaff Culture”, see https://joethebookguy.com/shop/archaeology/review-analysis-of-the-flagstaff-culture/ )  “About twelve hundred years ago, a group of people established themselves in the region north of the San Francisco Peaks near Flagstaff.  They settled on what is now the Baker Ranch, dug pit-houses to live in, built three or four contiguous rooms on the ground surface for storage, and smashed a lot of pottery which stamps the period of their culture as Pueblo I.  They later moved a little to the eastward and dug more pit-houses in Medicine Valley and nearby, but they now solved their storage problems by building one room surface houses, with a bulge on one side, which have been called Alcove Houses.  The pottery which they made places the period as Pueblo II.” (Page 1)

You may also like…